Club fitting - some thoughts
- keithfmuir
- Feb 6
- 8 min read
As a self-confessed golf nerd and (recovering) club junkie, I thought I was well-placed to write some thoughts about club fitting. The truth is, I love the club fitting process! I find it fascinating how seemingly small changes can make such a significant performance impact - shafts, heads, lofts, lie angles and how they all interplay. Today, I want to talk about how I get the most out of a fitting session and what benefits I see from custom-fitted clubs.
Why get fitted? Times have changed!
The best analogy I can come up with is that buying new clubs is a bit like buying a new suit. You can buy "off the rack" and get something that's close, but not perfect. You can buy "off the rack" and have it adjusted ("tailor-made") to fit. Or you can go full bespoke, with total control over all aspects of the finished item.
While it's easy to find retailers who will happily sell you equipment "off the rack", most manufacturers now also offer "tailor-made" options with a range of different shafts as standard. Once you add in the premium up-charge shafts, the choices can get bewildering. But how do you know what will work for you? Just because a certain head and shaft combo works for your favourite tour player, or it got a good (most likely paid-for) review on YouTube, or you liked your mate's clubs when you tried them, doesn't mean it's right for you. New clubs are more expensive than ever, so before spending your money, you owe it to yourself to have a fitting. Whether you go for a free service with your retailer or a premium fitting elsewhere, the choice is yours. For the reasons discussed below, you've got nothing to lose and potentially lots to gain.
Ideally - find a fitter you know and trust
Most of us will be members of a golf club, so a good place to start is with your club professional. Given they've got to see you every time you come to play, they are much less likely to sell you something that's not right for you. They may also suggest you take some lessons before buying clubs. During my lessons with Sandy Smith at Ladybank, he identified that my current irons were a poor fit (not enough spin) and suggested I review them when we finished our lessons. While he could do fittings, there was no pressure to use him. One of the downsides to club shops is that they generally only carry a limited range of clubs, with some not stocking clubs at all. If they don't offer fittings, ask your professional to recommend someone they know. Some manufacturers have regional fitting centres where appointments need to be booked by your professional or retailer. Callaway, for example, has a fitting centre at the St Andrews Academy.
I'm fortunate to have built good relationships with Adam at Auchterlonies and the team at SGGT. I've known Scott Gourlay for over 15 years, since his early days at Craigmillar Park in Edinburgh and have had several fittings with the team. I've built my relationship with Adam since I moved to St Andrews. He now knows my game well, plays the same courses as me and understands what I'm trying to get from my clubs.
Be prepared
You owe it to yourself (and your fitter) to be armed with as much information about your game as possible when you attend your session. This helps the fitter to understand your tendencies and assess your current equipment for suitability. If you've got ShotScope, Arccos, or other playing data, take it with you or send it to the fitter beforehand. I use the Tangent App (reviews here and here) and have found the data useful for both fittings and general game improvement. Think about your good and bad shots, your typical shot shape, do you miss greens left or right, long or short, what are the turf conditions like at your course, is the bunker sand firm or soft, what do you like or dislike about your current clubs etc.
Also, think about what you want to achieve from the fitting and be focused. Are you looking for distance, accuracy, more/less spin, forgiveness, feel etc. If you're not prepared, then you risk being poorly fitted. The irons mentioned above had been custom fit. I went into that fitting just a bit unhappy with my previous clubs and had no real idea of what I was looking for in new clubs. The focus of that (single brand) fitter was on distance (which flattered my ego at the time), so that poor fitting was my fault for not being prepared on the day. If I said I was struggling to stop the ball on the green, the fitting might have been very different.
Not all fittings are equal.....
...but any fitting is usually better than no fitting.
Most fittings will likely be conducted at a driving range, club practice facility or indoors in a net. Some will be brand-specific, while others will be brand-agnostic. Some will rely on the basic manufacturer fitting cart, while others will have a wider range of options. The best fittings will use premium balls rather than range balls and will also allow you to try the clubs off grass lies (which is especially important with irons and wedges). Some fitters (particularly your club pro) may allow you to take a demo club to try on the course. Indoor fittings are obviously not subject to weather conditions and enable you to use premium balls (or your own choice of ball). While I'm generally quite happy hitting into a net, my preference is to hit into the open so I can see the actual flight of the ball rather than relying on a computer simulation.
Over the years, I've done a wide variety of fittings. From single club sessions (usually driver) to irons, wedges and even full-bag reviews. From single-manufacturer to multi-brand. With irons, it's been common for the fitting to use just one club, usually a 6i or 7i and then get that shaft and head combination for the full set. For a large proportion of recreational golfers, that is probably adequate. But with the advent of hybrids and blended iron sets, how do you determine if the same clubs are right for you through the whole set? Should you still go with a 3, 4 or 5i? Do you have enough swing speed to hit a long iron well? Could you improve your speed with a different shaft in the long irons? Should you go with a hybrid? Do your distance gaps work throughout the set? With a single iron fitting, you either have to rely on the judgment of your fitter or simply guess. That's where a facility like SGGT comes into its own, as your fitting will involve trying 4, 6, 8 and PW, can bring hybrids in at the long end and will also look at the gaps to your woods.
When looking for graphite shafts last year, I had three fitting sessions covering all the styles discussed above. You can read about them in these posts:
Brand agnostic, full custom options:
Brand agnostic, single club used for fitting:
Brand specific but still single club used for fitting:
You can also read about my experience at the Titleist GT launch event
And my experience at a similar Callaway day
Short-term cost, long-term saving?
As previously mentioned, golf clubs are expensive, and most of us can't just chop and change whenever we fancy. You should come away from a fitting with peace of mind that you have the best clubs for you - especially if you've done a multi-brand fitting. Unless you are about to make radical swing changes (maybe wait before buying) or have an unexpected injury, your clubs should last several years. Most golfers will never play or practice enough to wear the clubs out! With every new release, manufacturers love to play the conditional happiness game, claiming their new clubs are "better" than the last one and will take your game to the next level. But a good fitting should help you resist the future temptation of new clubs - at least for a while. A well-fit driver, for example, should last you at least two generations of new releases, if not more. I saw that with the Titleist GT range (link) and the Callaway Paradym (link).
Some fitters can retrofit your existing clubs, which may offer a more economical solution to poorly fitted clubs. When looking at my irons last year, one of the considerations was to swap the shafts and keep my existing heads. With modern woods mostly having “screw-in" shafts, it has become much easier to fine-tune their performance. Don't give up on your existing kit too quickly. See if your fitter can improve it first.
You don't have to buy
You should never feel obliged to buy. If you are not convinced, then pay the fitting fee and walk away. But be honest with the fitter and tell them your concerns. They may offer to re-fit you at a later date or waive the fee. It is easy to get caught up in the experience of the day and the lure of the new clubs, but only you can decide if the (potentially marginal) gains are worth the (sometimes hefty) cost.
If you have paid for your fitting, you are perfectly entitled to ask for the fitting data and recommendations. Given how frequently new products are released, there is a good chance you can find your perfect clubs second-hand in a few months. Or even the same spec in a previous generation product. This is especially true of drivers and putters.
Psychological benefits:
Confidence through focusing on what you can control
I can't control the weather, the course conditions or the other players, but I can control the equipment I take onto the course with me. As an amateur golfer, I don't expect to go out and play like the professionals, but one way I can be level with them is through eliminating doubt about my equipment. We all know the phrase, "a bad workman blames his tools". Knowing I have the best tools for my swing takes that away. It clears my mind of doubt, letting me focus on the target and execute my shot.
My 3 wood is the only club in my bag that was not custom-fitted, and it's no real surprise that it's the one I am least comfortable with. Many fitters will tell you that fairway woods are notoriously difficult to fit and are often the oldest club in players' bags. When we find one that works, there's a tendency to keep it for a long time. Henrik Stenson still plays a Callaway Diablo from 2016 and describes it as his most reliable club.
Stop searching/tinkering
Some readers will probably say this is a bit rich coming from me, but a good custom-fitting session should allow you to step off the hedonic treadmill and accept that what you have is the best you can get. If you're a regular reader, you'll see that I've got a particular weakness for drivers and putters and have spent a lot of time (and money) on "experiments". I've fallen prey to the marketing of more yards or fewer three-putts, and despite having fitted clubs, I've continued to tinker. It's back to Solomon's Paradox from a previous post (link) - it can be easier to advise others than to take the advice yourself. But I am getting better!
If it hadn't been for my tendonitis last year, I would not have changed my irons, as the previous ones were already a good fit. Undoubtedly, I will still try new clubs and attend demo/launch days, but primarily because I enjoy the experience as part of my hobby. It also helps generate future review content for the blog!
Conclusion
I'm a great believer in custom fitting and I wholeheartedly recommend it to all golfers. It doesn't have to cost the earth and there's no obligation to buy. Clubs cost too much these days to buy them on-spec. I enjoy the experience and believe the Trackman data also helps me understand my game a bit better. Ultimately, it eliminates doubts about my equipment and helps me focus on playing with, rather than questioning, my kit.
p.s. If you've read this far and enjoyed the post, please subscribe to the blog. It doesn't cost anything, but it helps me write more posts like this one.
コメント